Reading The Color of Violence again by Incite! women of color. And like… if ever there was a case against abolition, it’s in this book lmfao. In two out of the three case studies of transformative justice after a man raped someone, the aggressor did not comply lmao. It is almost laughable if it wasn’t for the fact that baked into every procedure is the externalisation of harm onto the body of the woman.
I quote:
Scenario 1
Dan is a Black man in an urban area who is active in the movement to end racial profiling and police brutality. He is also works with young people to organize against institutional racism at an organization called Youth Empowered. He is well-known by progressives and people of color in the area and popular in the community. Over the course of three years, four young Black women (ages twenty-one and younger) who were being mentored by Dan approached CARA staff with concerns about ongoing sexual harassment within their activist community. Sexual harassment tactics reported by the young women included Dan bringing young people that he mentored to strip clubs, approaching intoxicated young women who he mentored to have sex with them, and having conversations in the organizing space about the size of women’s genitals as it relates to their ethnicity. The young women also asserted that institutional sexism within the space was a serious problem at Youth Empowered. Young women had fewer leadership opportunities and their ideas were dismissed.
[…]
Although we think that this work has created a safer environment at Youth Empowered, Dan still has not been accountable for his behavior. That is to say, he has not admitted that what he did was wrong or taken steps to reconcile with the people who he targeted at Youth Empowered. However, at the time of writing, we expect that he’ll continue to go to these meetings where these conversations about sexual violence (including his own) will be discussed in the context of building a liberation movement for all Black people.
Scenario 2
Kevin is a member of the alternative punk music community in an urban area. His community is predominantly young, white, multigendered, and includes a significant number of queer folks. Kevin and his close-knit community, which includes his band and their friends, were told by two women that they had been sexually assaulted at recent parties. The aggressor, Lou, was active and well-known in the music community, and he was employed at a popular club. Lou encouraged the women to get drunk and then forced them to have sex against their will.
[…]
Some members of the community may regret that they were ultimately unable to compel Lou to follow their demands. However, CARA feels that it’s not unreasonable to think that their work did have a significant impact on Lou. After experiencing the full force of collective organizing which asserted that his behavior was unacceptable, we venture to guess that Lou might be less likely to act in manipulative and abusive ways. In any case, we think their work may have also compelled other members of the community to think critically about the way in which consent operates in their sexual encounters, which is important work in preventing future sexual violence. Also, it’s important to remember that this community did, in fact, stay with their accountability process for the long haul-they now simply have their sights set higher than Lou.
The Color of Violence: The INCITE! Anthology edited by INCITE! Women of Color Against Violence; Taking Risks Implementing Grassroots Community Accountability Strategies, by a collective of women of color from Communities Against Rape and Abuse (CARA), p.256-259 (scenario 1) and p. 260-263 (scenario 2). Emphasis is my own
-
My thoughts on this: Failure! Abject, resounding, complete failure! And it’s all couched in vague cracker language!! “We expect” “conversations” “some may regret” “we venture to guess” “might be less likely”.
So it’s radical abolition all the way up until a man sexually harms a woman and then suddenly everyone defaults to sounding like a White House press secretary??
Also, the entire process is just centred around humanising the rapist man, protecting the rapist man from the prison system, ensuring the comfort of the rapist man throughout the process. Not once did I read of anything centring the victims mentality or process. Not once!!
Patriarchal! Mind bendingly patriarchal!! It’s giving plantation it’s giving obsequious African slave trader at Elmina Castle smilingly inviting the Europeans to take a look at the Africans held below, and trying to placate the wailing aggrieved families of the captives out the other side of their mouth. I swear, we Black people will never be free until we can stamp out this tendency of those among us to rush to placate the enemy.
It’s not just that they failed, what is gagging me is that they refuse to reckon with the failure in any meaningful way. It’s like when someone already has their conclusion and does their experiment after. The experiment does not produce the results they want, so they simply bend language until failure resembles success. Genuinely disgusting.
I encourage people to read it for themselves to draw their own conclusions.